Open Europe logo
open europe logo

Press Summary Archive

Hoon: parts of EU Constitution could be brought back without referendum

05 March 2007

Geoff Hoon was interviewed on the EU Constitution on the Sunday Edition yesterday.  He argued that the EU should drop the name “Constitution” for its new treaty and signalled that the Government would only hold a referendum if it comes back in its current form.  He said, “It seems to me much better, instead of talking about details of alleged Constitutions, that we actually concentrate on what the European Union does for its citizens and make sure that that is the debate that we have.” He argued that the EU already had a Constitution – its treaties and laws from the last 50 years.  He said, “The question is whether they should be encapsulated in a single document, a single piece of paper that is referred to as a Constitution.  I think very many people, even in countries that have ratified the existing treaty, believe that perhaps the use of the word 'Constitution' wasn't the most sensible decision".  Hoon said the Government would honour its promise to hold a referendum on a treaty - but only if the Constitution was agreed in its present form: "We've made it clear that if the constitutional treaty comes back in its present form then there would be a referendum," he said.

 

William Hague wrote in the Sunday Express that EU politicians must stop ignoring the will of the people and not push the EU Constitution through the back door. He said that the “proposals in the document [the Constitution] would do real damage to Britain’s interests” and that Labour must “honour the pledge it gave to hold a referendum on the Constitution”. Hague also said David Cameron will be meeting the Czech PM, Mirek Topolanek, on Tuesday to discuss a new agenda for the EU. 

No link

Reuters

 

Euro army ambitions damage NATO

The Sunday Express reported on how certain EU countries are not sending troops to the frontline in Afghanistan because they are distracted by ambitions to create a European Army. Open Europe Director Neil O’Brien said “some EU members are making it very difficult for Nato in Afghanistan because they are so obsessed with replacing Nato with a European Defence Force. The European Union is draining away resources to missions elsewhere in the world when we really need more people in Afghanistan”. 

 

Meanwhile in a speech on defence on Saturday French presidential hopeful Ségolène Royal said European defence has been “stalled for the last five years” and must be re-launched.  She said there was an “absolute necessity” for a sustained effort “in the field of research and the convergence of policies on equipment acquisitions.”  Le Figaro writes that in an attack on Nicolas Sarkozy’s perceived Antlanticism she said she did not advocate “following in the steps of the American administration” and that she would fight against NATO acquiring the role of “gendarme of the world, substituting the UN.”  Sarkozy is due to outline his proposals on defence on Wednesday.

Le Figaro

 

Cameron to signal new Conservative drive for EU reform

David Cameron’s speech to the Movement for European Reform’s first conference tomorrow is trailed in several UK newspapers.  The Times reports that it “will signal the start of a new engagement by his party with Europe, reforming it from the inside so that it moves from uniformity to diversity and from being an inward-facing bureaucracy to an outward-facing association of states. It would be one which devotes its energies to matters such as global warming, world poverty and creating a dynamic economy.” 

 

Cameron will say, “We want to work together with the peoples and parties of Europe who share our vision, to create a new union, a new union based not on uniformity and compulsion, but on diversity and voluntary cooperation of independent nation states. That is the vision we are working towards.  It is only by responding to the challenges of global competition and by opening up our economies to free trade that we will fight poverty in Africa. Ultimately it is enterprise, not aid that will save the developing world.”

Sun Times Telegraph

 

Chirac attacks Mandelson’s performance at the WTO

Jacques Chirac has criticised EU Trade Commissioner Peter Mandelson for making too many concessions to developing countries in the world trade talks. Chirac said that Mandelson "keeps wanting to give more even though the Americans have not shown any intention of making the slightest concession on farm products”.  He is quoted in Le Figaro saying he is “deeply shocked by some of the attitudes taken by Peter Mandelson”. Chirac has stated that France would show "rock-hard firmness" in defending its interests at the WTO negotiations. 

Guardian Reuters WSJ  Le Figaro

 

BBC gives advice on how to ‘sex up’ the EU elections

According to the Sunday Telegraph the BBC is giving advice to MEPs in an attempt to make the European Parliament elections more “viewer friendly”. The BBC has called for the use of more ‘visual aids’ and higher profile politicians on election night. The BBC is also among 26 channels to agree to broadcast live the 50th anniversary celebrations of the Treaty of Rome in Berlin.

Sunday Telegraph

 

Commissioner: French voters have “done a Zidane” to the EU and need to stop whingeing

According to the FT, Jacques Barrot, France's European Commissioner, has called for France to leave behind its "whingeing, pessimistic and defensive" mindset on Europe, and try to make more positive proposals for change.  He claimed that by voting no to the European Constitution in 2005, French voters "did a Zidane" to the Union, whilst the current presidential candidates have resorted to using the EU as a scapegoat for France's problems. Barrot concluded that France is suffering from an "Asterix syndrome", a reference to the cartoon Gaul who resists the Romans.  Barrot believes that a new EU treaty should not require ratification by referendum.

FT El Pais

 

Poland will not block new EU treaty if national sovereignty is respected

Danuta Hübner, Poland's EU Commissioner, has said that Poland would sign up to a new EU treaty as long as it does not mean a loss in national sovereignty. Hubner told FT Deutschland that "Poland will not be the one to block the treaty" if this precondition is met.  El Pais has a news feature arguing that “nationalist fever” has gripped Poland as a result of deteriorating relations with Germany, fear of Russia and concerns over revival of the EU Constitution. Meanwhile DPA reports that Roman Giertych, Poland's Deputy Prime Minister, has called for any new EU Constitution to ban abortion and gay rights.  He argued, “Europe needs changes.  Abortion must be banned immediately... Homosexual propaganda must also be limited so children will have the correct view of the family."

FT Deutschland Gazeta Wyborcza  El Pais  DPA

 

Times: Berlin Declaration to be used as a roadmap to ‘social Europe’ and EU Constitution

A leader in Saturday’s Times warned Tony Blair that he should look carefully at the “fine print” in the Berlin Declaration before signing it.  It predicted: “The festivities will be lavish, and the wrangling over what the anniversary really means will itself be the fireworks display. In the EU, symbolic occasions have a way of generating expansionist ambitions that become policy... It is already clear that this could be much more than a simple declaration. Many countries would like it to be a philosophical “road map” that will set the continent firmly back on course towards a Social Europe and a detailed constitution.”

Times-leader

 

Copenhagen has been rocked by 3 nights of rioting by anarchists which has led to over 600 arrests.

Independent

 

French election: Bayrou closing gap with Royal 

Several of the Sunday newspapers looked at the upcoming French presidential elections, with the Observer looking at the ‘Bayrou phenomenon’. According to a new poll for Le Figaro, UDF candidate François Bayrou has gained 6.5 points in the last fortnight – doubling his popularity to 18.5% over the last two months to move into third place ahead of Jean-Marie Le Pen and only 7 percentage points behind Ségolène Royal.  Nicolas Sarkozy remains the favourite with 31% while Royal is on 25.5%.  The poll showed that Sarkozy would win the second round with 54% of votes.

 

In the Sunday Telegraph William Langley argued that Ségolène Royal is “living proof of the argument that France needs to change”, quoting her telling a gathering of business leaders that “money is my lifelong enemy”.

Le Figaro  Le Figaro 2  Observer Sunday Telegraph Independent on Sunday Sunday Times

 

Booker: EU waste policy creating “national scandal”

Christopher Booker writes in the Sunday Telegraph on how local councils are implementing a policy of collecting “green waste” to comply with EU waste policy. EU waste policy is designed to phase out the use of landfill sites by fining local councils who fail to recycle enough waste. Booker notes that in fact much of the so called “green waste” is being sent to landfill sites therefore making a mockery of EU anti-landfill rules. The only positive outcome of this is the fact that councils will not be fined.

Sunday Telegraph

 

EU-India trade pact could stumble on “human rights and democracy” clause

The FT reports that a proposed EU-India free trade agreement (FTA) could be hindered by the inclusion of a standard clause on “human rights and democracy” in the pact. "This clause would, of course, be a deal-breaker," Kamal Nath, India's Commerce Minister, said in an interview. "This is meant to be a specifically targeted trade and investment agreement, which it will not be if other elements come into it." Analysts in India have voiced suspicions that clauses such as this reflect “protectionist cover” on the part of the EU.

FT

 

Norwegian daily Dagen reports that a recent opinion poll shows that Norwegians are becoming increasingly sceptical about the EU, with 51% opposing EU membership, compared to 37.6% in favour.

Dagen

 

The Reform Party has claimed victory in the Estonian parliamentary election, after narrowly beating its ruling partner the Centre Party. The Reform Party received 27.8 of the votes, up 10 percent from the last election.

IHT EUobserver Deutsche Welle Svenska Dagbladet

 

FT: EU should reverse ban on snus to combat smoking

John Gapper, writing in the FT, argues that the EU should reverse its ban on snus, a form of oral tobacco commonly used in Sweden (which has an opt-out from the EU ban), as this country has enjoyed huge success in reducing levels of smoking – which is a far more harmful form of tobacco use.

FT

 

Barroso: EU takes inspiration from Britain

In an interview with Saturday’s Times Jose Barroso claimed that “The Europe of the 21st century takes its inspiration in many ways from BritainBritain has this global approach, the approach that I am trying to push forward”.

Times

 

EU and US negotiators have agreed a “memorandum of understanding” on the open skies negotiations which could see BA’s stranglehold over transatlantic flights from Heathrow broken.  

Times Times2 AFP Guardian

 

EU-Microsoft dispute exposes flaws of EU competition policy

The WSJ writes in an opinion piece that the EU’s anti-trust office is flawed, stating that the EU is “punishing Microsoft for not meeting a standard that was never specified”. The WSJ also claims that as well as acting as “prosecuter, judge, jury and executioner in anti-trust cases” the EU is now claiming the power to “assess the worth of patents”.

WSJ

 

Turkey to present a “new strategy” on its EU relations

EUobserver reports that Turkish Economy Minister Ali Babacan has announced that Turkey will present a "new strategy" in response to EU leaders' decision last December to suspend eight out 35 chapters of Turkey's membership negotiating book.

EUobserver

 

 

World

 

The Sun reports that “British troops in Iraq are being bombarded by new rockets and mortars supplied by Iran.”

Sun

 

According to the Guardian China has announced a 17.8% rise in defence spending this year.

Guardian

 

The FT argues that while Iranian President Ahmadinejad may continue to enjoy his “man of the people” image, there are stirrings of discontent amongst the country’s elite as a result of the leadership’s aggressive foreign policy.

FT

 

UK

 

UKIP problems mount

Both the Sunday Times and the Sunday Telegraph reported on the increasing problems for UKIP.  The Sunday Telegraph revealed that a senior UKIP official made a donation to American Friends of BNP while living in the USA. David Abbott, who is on UKIP’s national executive committee, also attended a meeting in the US which featured the BNP leader, Nick Griffin, as a guest speaker. The Sunday Times reported that UKIP deliberately covered up the fact that Tom Wise, a UKIP MEP, embezzled nearly £40,000 of public funds by switching bank accounts with his secretary. UKIP have removed the whip from Wise after he admitted spending £6,500 of the money to buy a car.

Sunday Telegraph Sunday Times