Open Europe logo
open europe logo

Press Summary Archive

Lib-Dems make a third U-turn on referendum – will now vote with the Government

02 April 2008

 

 

The Liberal Democrats in the House of Lords will reverse the party’s position of abstaining on a referendum in the Commons, and will now vote with the Government against a referendum.  A Lib Dem abstention on a referendum in the Upper House would have significantly boosted the chances of a referendum.

 

Lord McNally, Lib Dem leader in the Lords said, "We will not abstain on a referendum amendment in the Lords. The arithmetic in the Commons is different from the Lords.” He told reporters outside the Lords chamber that he would not even be moving an amendment on continued membership of the EU. He added: "We will vote with the Government against a referendum on the treaty."

 

Director of the I Want a Referendum campaign Neil O'Brien is quoted on PA: "The Liberal Democrats promised a referendum at the election, abstained in the Commons, and are now against a referendum in the Lords. The Lib Dems have behaved in a deeply hypocritical and dishonest way, saying one thing and doing another.”

 

"This is a humiliation for Nick Clegg. He has been unable to make his own peers follow his policy. This is very damaging for the Liberal Democrats' credibility. Nick Clegg is now being pushed around by his own party, rather than leading it. It makes him look like a very weak leader."

 

Baroness Shirley Williams, who is rumoured to have threatened defection to Labour if the Lib Dems backed a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty said of the promise of a referendum: "That commitment was embarrassing. I believe it was not in the interests of this country or in the interests of a good relationship with the rest of the EU."

 

Conservative leader in the Upper House, Lord Strathclyde, said outside the chamber: "David Heath and two others [all frontbench Lib Dem MPs] had to resign in order to honourably uphold their manifesto commitment to a referendum. Lords McNally, Shutt and Thomas of Gresford are shadow cabinet members too. Why is Mr Clegg not making them resign if they don't abstain?”

 

Labour former leader Lord Kinnock, an ex-EU Commissioner, who also spoke in the debate, said the Treaty "does not create a single new competence for the EU".

BBC EUobserver Spectator Telegraph

 

Ahern to step down in May

Irish Taoisach Bertie Ahern has announced his resignation. The announcement comes a day after Mr Ahern began a court challenge to limit the work of a public inquiry probing planning corruption in the 1990s. Ahern insisted, “I have never received a corrupt payment and I've never done anything to dishonour any office that I've ever held."

 

Johnny Dymond has a piece on the BBC Today programme discussing the prospects for the referendum on the Lisbon Treaty in Ireland.

BBC Today BBC

 

French NATO reintegration dependent on enhanced EU defence capacity

There is much coverage of the opening of the NATO summit in Bucharest today, at which one of the big issues will be France’s plans to rejoin the integrated military structure of the Alliance.  However, Le Monde notes, “If, during the French EU Presidency which begins on 1 July, Washington does not support a real military planning and operations centre in Brussels, that will mean that Paris has no interest in retaking its full place within NATO as Sarkozy wants.” 

 

It also notes that as well as facing resisted by opposition parties, the plan is also opposed by Guy Tessier, the President of the National Assembly’s Defence Committee, who is from Sarkozy’s UMP party. Le Figaro reports that France will wait until April 2009 for NATO’s 60th anniversary before formally announcing its new rapprochement with the Alliance.

 

The Times notes that there are signs that earlier reports of 1,000 extra French troops in Afghanistan could already be unravelling, with Prime Minister François Fillon yesterday pledging “several hundred” extra troops to the mission.  The article reports on an acrimonious debate in the French Parliament yesterday, and notes that only 15 per cent of the public back the deployment.

 

The IHT reports that senior officials in the French Socialist opposition party have dubbed Afghanistan a "new Vietnam" and criticised what they called Sarkozy's "Atlantic obsession." According to the paper, Jouyet said the uproar illustrated that for Europe to reinforce its defense capacity, it was imperative to do so under a European banner. "If we want Europeans to back this, it needs a European identity," he said.

Le Figaro Le Monde Le Monde 2 Times IHT

 

The Guardian reports that David Miliband will today make “his most pro-European speech as foreign secretary”.

Guardian

 

Eurozone under strain as manufacturing sector divergence reaches eight year high

The WSJ reports that there is a growing divergence between healthy northern Eurozone economies and their southern counterparts. March figures from the Purchasing Managers Index show the manufacturing sector expanded in Germany, Austria and the Netherlands, but contracted in Italy, Spain and Ireland and showed weakness in France.

 

The results mark the most pronounced divergence among the 15 countries sharing the euro than at any time since the third quarter of 2000.

WSJ

 

Only 14 percent of MEPs have business experience

According to research carried out by the Industry and Parliament Trust, MEPs have much lower levels of business experience than members of the House of Commons. The report finds that only 14 per cent of MEPs have any business experience at all, only 9 percent have at least five years experience and just 5 percent have at least ten years experience. This compares to 28 percent, 21 percent and 13 percent respectively for Westminster MPs.    

FT

 

EU should allow us to emit more CO2 in compensation for nuclear phase-out, says Germany

German Finance Minister, Michael Glos, has said that Germany should be allowed to emit more carbon dioxide in compensation for phasing out its nuclear energy. Glos has written to his environment counterpart, Sigmar Gabriel, to say that Germany's planned nuclear phase-out must be taken into account when the EU is allocating CO2 permits to member states as part of its overall bid to lower greenhouse gas emissions from the bloc. Glos referred to the example of Sweden which at the end of the 1990s secured itself special treatment due to its nuclear phase-out. This meant that it was allowed to emit four percent more greenhouse gases between 1990 and 2012.

EUobserver FT

 

New Commissioner pledges to re-table controversial Health Directive in June

EUobserver reports that new Cypriot Commissioner Androula Vassiliou – who still needs the approval of the European Parliament - has pledged to move forward with the proposed EU Health Directive, which would govern patients’ rights to receive medical treatment in another EU member state and the rules on who is responsible for covering the costs. "I am already working on the proposal, and I am determined to submit it for adoption by the Commission in June," Vassiliou said, adding that it will be presented along with the Commission's pending social package, "promoting access, opportunities and solidarity for all EU citizens." The original proposal sparked plenty of controversy. "It would create two classes of citizens; those who can access the health services and those who can't and that is unacceptable," UK Labour MEP Linda McAvan is quoted as saying.

EUobserver

 

France appoints famous designer as “artistic director” for its EU Presidency

Bernard Kouchner wants the French EU Presidency to be “very creative” and has appointed well-known French designer Philippe Starck as “artistic director for the French EU Presidency.”  Starck says that, “Bernard Kouchner wants to mark a very, very vivid, very interesting, very creative French Presidency.” 

La Tribune de Geneve

 

Polish deputies approve EU Treaty

The Polish parliament has voted in favour of the Lisbon Treaty after weeks of argument. The opposition Law and Justice Party had threatened to vote against the treaty, fearing it could place limits on Polish sovereignty. President Lech Kaczynski also objected, putting forward an alternative bill before a compromise was reached.

BBC AP El Pais

 

McCreevy calls for “early warning system” in EU’s banking sector

Commissioner Charlie McCreevy yesterday told MEPs that “an early warning system” for the banking sector in the EU is urgently needed. He proposed changes to the so-called Basel II rules on capital requirements. There is also a proposal for a “supervisory college”, bringing together supervisors from different countries, to monitor the largest financial institutions within the EU.

FT

 

The European Commission has launched a formal investigation into the British government's bail-out plan for Newcastle-based Northern Rock.

BBC

 

World

 

Developing countries move to hoard food supplies

The front page of the FT reports that an increasing number of countries are seeking to lift tariffs and restrict exports – such as India and Vietnam with rice, and Ukraine with wheat – in response to the growing food shortage. Economists have warned that such moves could force up food prices – already high from the growing demand in emerging markets and increased production of bio fuels.

FT