Open Europe logo
open europe logo

Press Summary Archive

MEPs vote for pay increase and then to cover up European Parliament fraud

23 April 2008

Europe

  

MEPs voted yesterday to cover up a report showing widespread abuse of allowances worth £125 million every year. The MEPs also rejected calls, supported by the European Ombudsman, for the names of 407 MEPs who receive a second voluntary pension to be published. Officials have suggested that "a significant number" of MEPs illegally pay their personal contributions to the pension scheme from their office allowances.

Chris Davies, a Liberal Democrat MEP, attacked the latest cover-up as bringing "discredit and dishonour upon the entire parliament.”  He added, “Far from cleaning up their act, a majority of MEPs seem intent on allowing greed and self-interest to triumph over the proper financial management of public money".

 

European Voice reports that MEPs yesterday also approved the EU’s budget for 2006 – despite the Court of Auditors failing to sign off the EU’s accounts for the thirteenth year running. According to Danish daily Jyllands-Posten the budget was approved by 582 votes to 77. In return for approval, the EP demanded that the Commission adopted a new action plan under which member states will have to provide national declarations on the use of structural funds signed by finance ministers, or funds will be frozen. The EP also voted to increase the pay for its members and assistants, under a new statute that will come into force in 2009, and agreed that MEPs should not employ family members – although stopping short of making such a requirement legally binding.

 

The Telegraph notes that the requirement not to employ family members will be buried in “a general long-term review of allowances”, expected to take place over the next year, and quotes a parliamentary official saying, "Don't hold your breath, things have a way of disappearing like this."

Sun Telegraph EUobserver Mail Independent Swedish Television El Pais Jyllands-Posten European Voice

 

UK Government and EU Commission set for clash on biofuels

The front page of the FT reports that expectations of a rethink of support for biofuels in Europe and the US contributed to a record oil price of $120 a barrel yesterday.

 

Gordon Brown said yesterday that the UK could push for a change in the EU target to increase the proportion of biofuel to 10 per cent of road fuels by 2020. He said that if a UK Government review of the impact of biofuels now under way “shows that we need to change our approach, we will also push for change in EU biofuels targets”. UK Energy Minister Malcolm Wicks yesterday said, “It would be ridiculous if we fill up our cars with 5-10 per cent of biofuels if the consequences are that somewhere else in the world people are not being fed.” He said, “We need to have a second look [at the EU’s biofuels target]. I think we will.”

 

Nonetheless, the European Commission has been defending its 10 per cent target. Asked by reporters on Monday whether the EU was reconsidering its position on the biofuels target, a spokesman said: “The answer is very simple. No.”

Swedish Radio FT Times Times 2 BBC Today (20 mins in) Scotsman Independent El Pais EUobserver Telegraph

 

Lib Dems in the Lords will not table any amendments to Lisbon Treaty Bill – claim we don’t need any more scrutiny

PA reports that the Liberal Democrats in the Lords have not tabled any amendments to the European Union (Amendment) Bill, which brings into force the Lisbon Treaty. The Conservatives, crossbenchers and UKIP peers have tabled nearly 170 amendments for the Bill's six-day committee stage, which began yesterday. However, there are no amendments from the Liberal Democrats.

 

Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg controversially ordered his MPs to abstain in the Commons on a demand from the Conservatives for a referendum on the Treaty, sparking three frontbench resignations. However, the Lib Dems in the Lords have changed from this position, and are set to support the Government in the Upper House.

 

For the Conservatives, Lord Howell of Guildford said: "I am actually amazed that they have not put down a single amendment and they really seem to have given up on their proper duty of scrutiny and improvement in this chamber. I thought that was what they were here for… I now wonder why they have bothered to walk into the Lords today, if they are not going to play any part in the Bill except to tick the Brussels boxes."

 

For the Lib Dems, Lord Wallace of Saltaire replied: "It is not line-by-line scrutiny that we need. Line-by-line scrutiny of the treaty has already been well undertaken by well over 100 peers in the Lords EU select committees."

PA

 

Europaportalen reports that a revised version of the Commission’s Health Directive will be re-tabled on June 25.

Europaportalen

 

EU to propose oil stocks directive that could cost UK £6bn

The Guardian reports that the European Union has launched a public consultation over the oil reserves member states hold to cushion themselves against unexpected oil crises. The Commission has indicated that it is planning to announce a legislative proposal in the second half of the year, the paper notes. A previous EU proposal, which would have increased emergency oil stocks to 120 days, was blocked by the UK and other member states in 2003. The Government estimated that the rejected proposal would have cost £3bn to implement. Research by Open Europe suggests that the implementation cost would now be over £6bn.
Forbes Guardian Open Europe Research

 

Legal bid to force a referendum goes ahead

The Telegraph reports on businessman Stuart Wheeler’s legal bid to force a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty. Rabinder Singh QC argued in the High Court yesterday that the Government had created “a legitimate expectation” that it would hold a vote and that ministers’ decision to “resile from their promise” should be declared unlawful. The judge indicated that he would consider the case over the next few weeks.

Stuart Wheeler's website 

 

Denmark to review its opt-outs from the Treaties – referendum in September?

The Danish centre-right minority government is to invite other domestic political parties to discuss its opt-outs from the European Union, Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen said yesterday. Rasmussen told reporters that the invitation would include the pro-EU parties in Parliament. Denmark joined the EU in 1973, but obtained opt-outs after voters initially rejected the Maastricht Treaty in a 1992 referendum. The opt-outs relate to the euro and certain aspects of security and defence policy, and justice and home affairs. Rasmussen said the opt-outs were no longer necessary and "contrary to fundamental Danish interests."

Earth Times

 

French Europe Minister: We must have single position on Olympics;

We are European, not atlanticists

In an interview with Polish daily Gazeta Wyborcza last week, which is published on the French Foreign Office site, Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner says “We really need a European pact on migration and asylum.  For countries like France, Spain or Italy, this problem is becoming more and more pressing.  We must respect asylum policy and human rights, and, at the same time, regulate the flow of immigrants.” 

Meanwhile, in an interview with Europe 1, also last week, French Europe Minister Jean-Pierre Jouyet said: “There will have to be a common [EU] position concerning the opening ceremony” of the Olympic Games.  He says “It will be up to the President of the Republic, who will be the President in charge of the EU at that moment, to make sure that there is a European position.  We are taking up the EU Presidency on 1 July, but there will be a European Council under the Slovenian Presidency at the end of June.  You could very well have a common position taken from the end of June by the Europeans.”  He said “The President of the Republic will need this common position to be able to determine his own position.”  Jouyet also denied that the government is becoming more ‘atlanticist’, saying “I don’t think there has been a shift towards the Atlantic.”  He said: “I have my convictions.  They are European and not ‘atlantacist’.  The important thing is that we favour the construction of a European defence.”  Asked whether Italy under Berlusconi will be a problem for France, he said: “I hope we will get the best Berlusconi, the one that wants to reform, that wants to move forward on the economic level and who wants a political Europe.  On all of those levels, we will obviously cooperate well with Italy.”  Jouyet said: “The French President’s dream is to ensure that Europe becomes a political reality, that it is less a non-identified object than a concrete, political Europe which, in particular, takes hold of its destiny.”

 

In an article in Le Figaro, Graham Watson, the leader of the ALDE group  in the European Parliament, writes: “Rarely has a member of the EU taken so much care in preparing its presidency of the Council as France in 2008”.

French Foreign Office

 

Dutch MPs call for strengthening of interparliamentary links amid concern that Lisbon Treaty provisions are “just empty words”

Agence Europe reports that two Dutch MPs, Luuk Blom from the ruling PvdA and Han ten Broeke of the opposition VVD, have called for a strengthening of COSAC – the body which has brought together national parliaments' European affairs committees and representatives of the European Parliament twice a year since 1989.  They want it to become the place where national parliaments adopt their stances on all Commission proposals, meaning it would have to become more structured, meet at least every two months, and have its administrative capacity reinforced.  They said: “It is only by creating good coordination between national parliaments that we can guarantee that their new powers of scrutiny on subsidiarity and proportionality, provided for by the Lisbon Treaty, will not be just empty words.”  They will invite their European colleagues to take up the call at the next COSAC meeting in Ljubljana on 7-8 May.  They say that several parliaments (Belgium, the Czech Republic, Germany, Ireland and Sweden) have already indicated their support.  The two MPs are also proposing to hold COSAC meetings and all European summits in Strasbourg, with Brussels becoming the only seat of the European Parliament.

No link

 

France to get EU justice portfolio in Commission reshuffle –

Italy to get transport to save Alitalia?

The Coulisses de Bruxelles blog reports that Commission President Jose Barroso yesterday released a statement saying that if Franco Frattini leaves to become a member of the Italian government, current Transport Commissioner Jacques Barrot will take over from him as Justice and Internal Affairs Commissioner, and the Italian government will appoint a Commissioner to fill the transport portfolio. 

 

The blog notes that France “will inherit an eminently sensitive portfolio just as JHA, thanks to the Lisbon Treaty which will enter into force in January 2009, becomes a community matter.  This means that the Commission will rediscover its monopoly of initiative, and qualified majority voting and co-decision with the European Parliament will become the rule.  It will therefore be the end of paralysing unanimity and minimum harmonisation.  Barrot will be able to make his mark on the new institutional mechanisms that will have to be established.  In Italy, they’re not unhappy either to find themselves with the transport portfolio just when the Commission is about to make an announcement about the future of Alitalia, the national airline company.”

 

BBC Europe Correspondent Mark Mardell however judges this interpretation to be “wide of the mark”, and sees the move as an attempt by Barroso to ‘get his own back’ at Berlusconi. European Voice notes that Italian MEP Antonio Tajani is expected to be nominated as Italy’s EU Commissioner.

Coulisses de Bruxelles El Pais EUobserver BBC

 

Berlin leaves door open for Blair EU Presidency bid

The FT reports that Germany is leaving the door open for Tony Blair to become a candidate for the European Union presidency but is not going so far as to offer public support. Berlin says there is no "anti-Blair pact" or plot among EU countries to prevent Blair from becoming president, in spite of reports that Angela -Merkelis at the heart of opposition to his candidature.

FT

 

Germany to quash EU climate change ambitions?

An article in Le Figaro asks whether the French EU Presidency, under pressure from Germany, will be the “gravedigger” of EU ambitions in the fight against climate change. It notes that Germany is increasingly critical of the Commission’s plans, which will be negotiated and finalised by the end of December.  It says that Berlin is not questioning the EU’s renewables and carbon reduction targets, but “Merkel’s government, which is demanding more flexibility, refuses to let the conditions be dictated by Brussels.”  The Germans are particularly irritated by a proposal to reduce emissions specifically in the automobile sector.

No link

 

Commission proposes working group to reconcile free movement and unions’ rights

Swedish Radio reports that the EU Commission has proposed that a ”working group” will look into how free movement and unions’ rights can be reconciled, following the recent labour market rulings in the Viking- Laval and Ruffert cases. The group will also look into how different member states’ labour market rules relate to one another. Swedish Social Democrat Jan Andersson – who leads a similar working group in the European Parliament – is quoted saying that the proposal “will not be enough to prevent social dumping.”

Swedish Radio

 

Le Monde reports that France is keen to avoid a WTO agreement on agriculture, which the head of the WTO Pascal Lamy wants before the end of May.

Le Monde

 

MEPs call for EU stance on communist crimes

Several MEPs have called on the EU to formally recognise crimes committed by Stalinist regimes and compensation for its victims on the same terms as victims of the Nazis. However, the European United Left/Nordic Green Left (GUE-NGL) grouping in the Parliament is opposed to equating the crimes of Nazism with those of Stalinism. The GUE-NGL brings together MEPs from left-wing parties, including some who while not supporting Stalinism still call themselves communists.

EUobserver

 

EU carving up Europe into regions

Coinciding with St George’s day, several papers look at the EU’s “regional map”, which divides Europe into regions with no reference to countries. It is noted that the EU in some instances also has facilitated separate cross-border regional administrations, as in the case of the Transmanche region of Southern England and Northern France, which has its own “assembly”. A leader in the Sun argues, “This is the latest step in the accelerating collapse of British sovereignty — and the unstoppable growth of unaccountable EU power.”

Sun Sun leader Telegraph Mail

 

The IHT notes that European countries are due to build about 50 coal-fired plants over the next five years, which will be in use for the next five decades.

IHT

 

A survey compiled by the Economist Intelligence Unit has identified Denmark as the best place in the world to conduct business, followed by Finland, Singapore, Canada and Switzerland.

European Voice

 
Turkey could join the European Union in 10 to 15 years if it remains fully committed to the reform path, EU Enlargement Commissioner Olli Rehn has said.

EUobserver